The Controversial Anti-Riot Bill Becomes Law



 The death of George Floyd in Minneapolis and subsequent cases of alleged police brutality have sparked civil unrest and violence throughout our nation over the past year. Florida has had comparatively little civil unrest. However, Governor Ron DeSantis signed into law on April 19, 2021, what he stated to be “the strongest anti-rioting, pro-law enforcement piece of legislation in the country.” The “Combating Public Disorder Act” went into effect immediately, vastly increasing law enforcement’s powers. It has caused an outcry from civil rights groups, alleging that it violates Florida citizens’ constitutional rights. The governor’s office contends that the purpose of the anti-riot law is to “protect businesses, supports law enforcement, and ensures punishment for those who cause violence in our communities.”  

Some of the Provisions of the 61 Page Anti-Riot Law include:

  • The creation of new crimes such as mob intimidation, cyber-intimidation by publication, rioting, and aggravated rioting, which carry prison sentences of up to 15 years.
  • Defining the destruction of historical markers, memorials, or statues as crimes, punishable for up to 10 years in prison.
  • Enhanced penalties for assaulting law enforcement, including a mandatory minimum jail sentence of six months for the assault or battery of a law enforcement officer during a riot.
  • Penalizing local governments who look to defund law enforcement through budget reductions.
  • Those charged with a misdemeanor arrest during a protest will be denied bail until their first court appearance.
  • Excessive bail fines for arrest in protests
  • Grants civil immunity to those who drive through protesters that are blocking a road.
  • Blocking a road is a felony offense.

A Federal Lawsuit has been Filed 

The opponents of the anti-riot law claim that it is unconstitutional. It violates the First Amendment, the Eighth Amendment, and the Fourteenth Amendment of the United States Constitution. A lawsuit has been filed in the U.S. District Court in Orlando against Governor Ron DeSantis, Attorney General Ashley Moody, and Orange County Sheriff John Mina. The lawsuit alleges that the anti-riot law violates the First Amendment by silencing the people who have a right to freedom of speech and the right to assemble. It violates the Eighth Amendment by administering cruel and unusual punishment. Finally, it violates the Fourteenth Amendment as it strips citizens of their protection of due process.

 Other Opponents of the Anti-Riot Law

The American Civil Liberties Union says the law is “overbroad and vague.” There is no well-defined concept of what constitutes a riot, and this gives law enforcement broad discretion. There are concerns that law enforcement could use the law against peaceful protesters and organizers. For example, if three or more people are standing on or remaining in the street, it is now a crime of an unlawful assembly and a civil infraction. The Florida Conference of Catholic Bishops are opposed to the new law over concerns about protests being shut down in front of abortion clinics.

The AP Law Group will Protect your Liberty and your Reputation

The United States Constitution contains the fundamental rights of every American, guaranteeing each of us protections and freedoms. The government must not infringe on these rights. At the AP Law Group, we are dedicated to protecting the citizens of Florida. If you are detained or arrested and believe your constitutional rights have been violated, we will explore your options and fight for justice. As seasoned criminal defense attorneys, we represent clients in a full range of criminal and civil rights matters for state and federal laws. We analyze and strategize complex legal issues in these confusing and controversial times to achieve the most favorable outcome.

With extensive trial experience, our law firm handles courtroom litigation confidently and effectively. If you have been charged with a crime related to the anti-riot law, we will ensure that your rights are not trampled on. Call us immediately if you have been detained or arrested for misdemeanor or felony charges.

The AP Law Group has offices in Ocala and Gainesville, Florida. Call us to make an appointment to meet with a knowledgeable and compassionate attorney at 352-732-9191. We are committed to finding solutions and achieving results.